The Contribution of Intimate Partner Violence to Health Disparities for Women of Color
Phyllis W. Sharps, PhD, RN, FAAN
Health disparities are defined as differences in access to care, processes of health care or health outcomes. The gap between health care access and health outcomes continues between minority and non-minority populations in this country. Women of color and their children compared to non-minority families are at greater risk for health disparities, including access to care, processes of health care and health outcomes. The context of their lives, which often includes lower levels of education, higher rates of poverty, and higher vulnerability to intimate partner violence (IPV) contributes significantly to these health disparities which are manifested in decreased access to health care, shorter life expectancy, higher rates of infant mortality, greater prevalence of chronic diseases, certain cancers and infections, as well as traumatic injuries from IPV.
Minority Women and Health Disparities
Women represent more than half of the total U.S. population and 46% of the nation’s workforce. Women continue to experience health disparities (DHHS 2001; Institute of Medicine National Research Council, 2002), compared to males, substantiating the need for attention to women’s health. There has been a shift in the biomedical paradigm to frameworks that include the social and contextual influences on health that are different for different groups of women (Mirsa, 2001). Consideration of social context seems to be particularly important for examining the health status of poor women and women of color.
“Women of color are more likely to have lower levels of education, live in poverty and in addition have less access to health care and other resources”
Woman of color suffer disproportionately from premature death, disease and disability (DHHS, 2001). In 1998, the ethnic/racial make-up of the total population of 103.8 million women was as follows: 71% Euro-American, 13% African American, 11% Hispanics, 4% Asian/Pacific Islanders and 1% American Indian/Native Alaskan. Since 2000, the proportion of women of color has increased dramatically, but their health status continues to lag behind white women. Ethnic/racial background in the U.S. influences many aspects of health and well being; for example, Euro-American women’s average life expectancy is 5 years longer that that of African American women (DHHS, 2001). Poverty, lack of education, and unemployment are more concentrated among women of color and are related to life expectancy (DHHS, 2001). Although in absolute numbers more Euro-American women live in poverty, proportionately more African American and Hispanic women live in poverty than any other group (Mirsa, 2001). Gaps still persist in education between men and women. Although these gaps are decreasing and in some aspects disappearing, the greatest gains have been made among Euro-American women. For example, more Euro-American women have a college education compared to African American women, and more African American women have less than a high school education compared Euro-American women (Mirsa, 2001). Educational levels are related to health behaviors. African American and Hispanic women, as well as low income women, are less likely to exercise on regular basis; more African American women are obese, and fewer use calcium supplements compared to Euro-American women. Other health behaviors patterns are not consistent across ethnic/racial groups. Overall, African American and Euro-American women smoke cigarettes in the same proportions, and both smoke more than Hispanic women, although in general, women living below the poverty level smoke more. African American women use alcohol less (past year use) compared to Euro-American and Hispanics, but African American women use more illicit drugs (past year use) compared to Euro-American and Hispanic women (Mirsa, 2001).
Women of color are more likely to have lower levels of education, live in poverty, and, in addition, have less access to health care and other resources (DHHS, 2001). This social context of their lives significantly influences their health care utilization rates, health status and health outcomes. These context variables are thought to account for much of the greater prevalence of chronic illnesses such as cardiovascular disease, lupus, certain types of cancer, diabetes, certain infections such as hepatitis, tuberculosis and AIDS among women of color (DHHS, 2001). Moreover, these contextual factors are also strongly linked to the greater severity and premature deaths related to these diseases (DHHS, 2001).
Intimate Partner Violence Against Women and Health Consequences
Over the last decade, violence against women has received increased attention among health care researchers and practitioners (IOM NRC, 2002; Humphreys, Campbell, & Parker, B, 2001). This increased attention is related to viewing violence against women as a complex health problem instead of just a criminal or social problem (Gerlock, 1999). Violence against women is now viewed as a major public health problem that is at epidemic levels and threatens the health and well being of approximately 2 million women and their children (Plichta, 1996). IPV is defined in this article as repeated physical and sexual assault by an intimate partner within a context of coercive control (Campbell & Humphreys, 1993).
Data from two major national population-based surveys have shown that violence perpetrated by intimates i.e., spouses, ex-spouses, boyfriends and ex-boyfriends, accounted for 21-25% of the violent crime experienced by women and 2-8% of violent crime experienced by men (Moffitt, & Caspi, 1999, Tjaden & Thoennes, 2000). Recent data also indicated that the rates of non-lethal IPV are highest among women aged 16 – 24, and women residing in low-income households, (Greenfeld, Rand, Craven, et.al.1998). African American women are disproportionately killed by abusive partners in comparison to white women, with unemployment significantly greater among those killed and the perpetrators (Campbell et al, 2003). Among African American women between the ages of 15 – 24 years, IPV is the leading cause of premature death from homicide, and injury from non-lethal causes (Rennison & Welchans, 2000). Several population based surveys have found that IPV is significantly more common among women of color, particularly African American and Native American women, although when differences in income, education and/or employment are considered, the differences attributable to race decrease or disappear (Jones, Campbell, Schollenberger, et.al.,1999; Tjaden & Thoennes, 2000; Walton-Moss et al, 2005). Since low income and underemployment are most common among women of color, the increase in rates of IPV experienced among them must be considered as a potential cause of disparities in health conditions shown to be associated with IPV.
The National Violence Against Women Survey (Tjaden & Thoennes, 2000) also reported that an intimate injured 41% of women compared to 19% of men, and that most received some type of medical treatment. Immediate traumatic injuries included broken bones, lacerations, facial trauma, tendon and ligament injuries and pain. Women of color are overrepresented in emergency departments and in injury data bases. In addition to the immediate traumatic injuries women receive from IPV, there are significant consequences to their physical and mental health. Empirical findings from several studies (Campbell et al, 2002; Coker et al, 2002, 2004) and comprehensive reviews of health consequences of IPV (Campbell 2002, Nauman, Langford, Torres, et.al., 1999; Sharps & Campbell 1999; Humphreys, Campbell, & Parker 2001) describe a variety of health outcomes. Battered women compared to non-battered women use more primary care and mental health services, spend more days in bed due to illness and are more likely to describe their health as fair or poor. Chronic physical conditions for which IPV is a significant risk factor include gastrointestinal disorders (loss of appetite, eating disorders), neurological problems (fainting or passing out, severe headaches, vision and hearing problems) urinary tract and other infections, and shortness of breath (Campbell 2002; Nauman, Langford, Torres, et.al., 1999; Sharps & Campbell, 1999).
Among female IPV survivors, 40-45% are forced into sex by male intimate partners (Campbell & Soeken, 1999). Forced sex is associated with acute and chronic reproductive health problems, including increased pelvic inflammatory disease, increased risk of sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV/AIDS, vaginal and anal tearing, dysmenorrhea, sexual dysfunction and pelvic pain (Campbell 2002, Nauman, Langford, Torres, et.al.,1999). From 3-19% of pregnant women are battered with associated adverse outcomes for both mothers and infants (Campbell, Garcia-Moreno & Sharps, 2003). Maternal consequences include traumatic injury, increased miscarriage, increased unintended or mistimed pregnancy, poor weight gain, increased risk for sexually transmitted and urinary tract infections, increased substance use including cigarette smoking and late entry into prenatal care. Neonatal and infant consequences include fetal injury, low birth weight, preterm delivery and substance exposure (Nauman, Langford, Torres, et. al., 1999, Sharps & Campbell, 1999). Poor maternal child outcomes of pregnancy are also more common among women of color, yet the possible connections specifically with IPV in contributing to these health disparities are seldom considered separately.
Female IPV survivors suffer increased mental health problems, accounting for much of the increased health care costs from IPV (Wisner, Gilmer, Saltzman, et.al., 1999). Depression is the primary response of battered women to IPV (Campbell, Kub, Belknap, et. al., 1996). Other mental health problems for women survivors of IPV include posttraumatic stress disorders (PTSD), increased substance use including alcohol, illegal drugs and cigarettes (Sharps & Campbell 1999; Campbell & Soeken, 1999; Sharps, Campbell, & Campbell, et. al., 2001). Again, women of color are more likely to experience PTSD, smoke and to use illegal drugs than are Anglo women, but the relative contribution of IPV to these health disparities are usually not specifically identified.
“Among African American women between the ages of 15 to 24 years, IPV is the leading cause of premature death from homicide and injury from non lethal causes.”
Although most studies of IPV suggest that poor women and women of color, especially African American women, are more at risk for IPV, injuries from IPV, and the physical and mental health effects of IPV (Tjaden & Thoennes, 2000; Plichta, 1996), the specific effects of IPV on the health of African American women have seldom been studied specifically. The few investigations that have been conducted (e.g. Schollenberger, Campbell, Sharps, et. al., 2003; Sharps, Campbell, & Campbell, et. al., 2001; Price, 1996; Torres, Campbell, Campbell, et. al., 2002; Jones, Campbell, Schollenberger, et. al.,1999) are a beginning effort. IPV health effects specific to African American women included higher rates of hypertension and higher rates of emergency department use for IPV injuries in abused African American women compared to Euro-Americans, and more low birth weight infants among abused African American women than white and Latina (Price, 1996; Jones, Campbell, Schollenberger, et.al.,1999). Campbell (Campbell, & Soeken, 1999) has also examined depression and IPV in a diverse sample and found that for African American women IPV was a significant predictor of depression and the depressive effects of IPV lasted long after the IPV ended. More research is needed to identify the health needs of African American and other minority ethnic female survivors of IPV.
The numbers of women dying from HIV/AIDS and the large racial disparities in morbidity and mortality in this disease warrant particular attention to the IPV/HIV-AIDS interface. The harsh reality of the new face of the HIV/AIDS epidemic is that women all around the world are being infected in the largest proportions, and that in Africa, they are the majority of those infected, and the majority of those dying. It is well documented in the United States that women of color are those who are the most affected by this particular health disparity. The intersections of HIV/AIDS and IPV are increasingly being recognized and definitively documented with persuasive and rigorous research (e.g. Dunkle, 2004; Gielen, O’Campo et. al., 1997; Greenwood, Relf et. al., 2002; Maman, Campbell et. al., 2000; Maman, Mbwambo, Campbell et. al., 2002; Relf, 2001; Whetten et al, 2006; Wingood, 2001; Wingood & DiClemente, 1997; Wyatt et. al., 2002). Since women of color are most frequently the victims of sexual violence by intimate partners as well as others, they are most often affected by this intersection and it is for them that the issues are most critical.
In the United States and all around the world, there are glaring disparities in the health of women of color in comparison to white women. This reality is well recognized as is the reality of intimate partner violence for large proportion of women. Yet these two intersecting issues are seldom considered together in spite of the documentation of more IPV among women of color and IPV as a risk factor for many conditions where health disparities are well documented. More research is needed to further unravel these connections, for instance, to determine if the health disparities are related to differential causation specific to IPV, lack of access to care for poor and minority ethnic women and/or differential lack of health care system recognition of violence, or differential rates in obtaining treatment because of the controlling behavior of abusive partners. Until these issues are determined, the culturally appropriate strategies and type of setting for health care system interventions for abused women will remain undetermined. As health care system interventions for domestic violence are developed and tested, it is imperative that they be tested specifically among different racial, ethnic and cultural groups or we may contribute to widening health disparities for abused women of color rather than narrowing the gaps.
Abdool Q, Karim. (2001) Barriers to preventing human immunodeficiency virus in women: experiences from KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Journal of American Medical Women’s Association, 56(4),193-196.
Campbell, J. C. (2002). Violence against women and health consequences. The Lancet. 359 (9314), 1331-1336.
Campbell, J.C. & Humphreys, J. (1993). Nursing care of survivors of family violence. St. Louis, MO: Mosby.
Campbell, J. C. & Soeken, K. S. (1999). Forced sex and intimate partner violence: Effects on women's health. Violence Against Women 5 (9): 1017-1035.
Campbell, J.C., & Soeken, K. (1999). Women’s responses to battering over time. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 14(1), 21-40.
Campbell, J.C., Garcia-Moreno, C., Sharps, P. (2004). Abuse during pregnancy in industrialized and developing countries. Violence Against Women 10 (7), 770-789.
Campbell, J.C., Kub, J., Belknap, R.A., & Templin, T. (1996). Predictors of depression in battered women. Violence Against Women,9, 99-111.
Campbell, J. C., Webster, D., Koziol-McLain, J., Block CR, Campbell, D., Curry, MA, Gary, F, Sachs, C. Sharps, PW, Wilt, S., Manganello, J., Xu, X. (2003). Risk factors for femicide in abusive relationships: Results from a multi-site case control study. American Journal of Public Health, 93, 1089-1097.
Campbell, D., Sharps, P.W., Gary, F. Campbell, J., Lopez, L. (2002). African American women and domestic violence. Online Journal of Nursing Issues. 7(1), Ms. 5.
Campbell, J. C. Snow-Jones, A., Dienemann, J., Kub, J., Schollenberger, J., O’Campo, P., Carlson-Gielen, A. (2002). Intimate partner violence and physical health consequences. The Archives of Internal Medicine, 162, 1157-1163.
Department of Health and Human Services (2001). Women’s health issues: An overview. Office on Women’s Health, Washington, D.C.: DHHS.
DHHS (2000). Healthy People 2010 (2 ed). With Understanding and Improving Health and Objectives for Improving Health. 2 vols. Washington, D.C.
Dunkle, K., Jewkes, R., Brown, R., Gray, G., McIntyre, J., & Harlow, S. (2004). Gender-based violence, relationship power, and risk of HIV infection in women attending antenatal clinics in South Africa. The Lancet, 363, 1415-1421.
El-Bassel, N., Gilbert, L., Krishnan, S., Schilling, R., Gaeta, T., Purpura, S. & Witte, S. (1998). Partner violence and sexual HIV-risk behaviors among women in an inner-city emergency department. Violence and Victims, 13 (4), 377-393.
Gerlock, A. (1999). Health impact of domestic violence. Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 20: 373-385.
Gielen, A. C., O'Campo, P., Faden, R. R., & Eke, A. (1997). Women's disclosure of HIV status: Experiences of mistreatment and violence in an urban setting. Women and Health, 25 (3), 19-31.
Gielen, A. C., McDonnell, K. A. , Burke, J. G., & O'Campo, P. (2000). Women's lives after an HIV-positive diagnosis: disclosure and violence. Maternal and Child Health Journal. 24 (2), 111-120.
Gilbert, L., El-Bassel, N., Rajah, V., Foleno, J. Fontdevila, V. Frye, and B. L Richman. (2002). The Converging Epidemics of Mood-Altering Drug Use, HIV, HCV, and Partner Violence: A Conundrum for Methadone Maintenance Treatment. The Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine, 67 (5 and 6), 452-463.
Garcia-Moreno, C., & Watts, C. (2000). Violence against women: Its importance for HIV/AIDS prevention. AIDS, 24 (3), S253-S265.
Greenfeld, L.A., Rand, M.R., Craven, P.A., Klaus, C.A., Perkins, C.A., Ringel, C., Warchol, G., Maston, C., & Fox, J.A. (1998). Violence by intimates: Analysis of data on crimes by current of former spouses, boyfriends and girlfriends. Bureau of Justice Statistics Factbook, Washington, D.C.: Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics, March, NCJ 167237.
Greenwood, G. L., Relf, M. V., Huang, B., Pollack, L. M., Canchola, J. A., & Catania, J. A. (2002). Battering Victimization Among A Probability-Based Sample of Men Who Have Sex With Men (MSM). American Journal of Public Health, 92 (12), 1964-1969.
He, H.; McCoy, H.; Stevens, S.; Stark, M. (1998). Violence and HIV Sexual Risk Behaviors Among Female Sex Partners of Male Drug Users. Women and Health. 27, 161-175.
Humphreys, J. C., Campbell, J.C., & Parker, B. P. (2001). Intimate partner violence against women. In: Annual Review of Nursing Research, (D. Taylor & N. Fugate-Woods, ed.). New York, N.Y.: Springer Publishing Company, pp. 275-306.
Humphreys, J., Lee, K., Neylan, T., & Marmar, C. (2001). Psychological and physical distress of sheltered battered women. Health Care for Women International. 22:401-414.
Institute of Medicine, National Research Council. (2001). Confronting chronic neglect: The education and training of health professionals on family violence
. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
Jewkes R; Levin J; Mbananga N; Bradshaw D (2002). Rape of girls in South Africa. Lancet. 26; 359(9303):319-320.
Jinich, S.; Paul, J.; Stall, R. et al. (1998). Childhood Sexual Abuse and HIV-Risk Taking Behavior Among Gay and Bisexual Men. AIDS and Behavior. 2, 41-51.
Jones. A.S., Campbell, J.C., Schollenberger, J., O’Campo, P.J., Dienemann, J.A., Gielen, A.C., Kub, J., &Wayne, E.C. (1999). Annual and lifetime prevalence of partner abuse in a sample of female HMO enrollees. Women’s Health Issues, 9(6), 295-305.
Karim, Q.; Karim,S.; Dipdata, M; Soldan, K.; Zondi, M. (1995). Reducing the Risk of HIV Infection among South African Sex Workers: Socioeconomic and Gender Barriers. American Journal of Public Health, 85, 1521-1525.
Maman, S.; Campbell, J.; Sweat, M.; Gielen, A. (2000). The Intersections of HIV and Violence: Directions for Future Research and Interventions. Social Science and Medicine. 50 (4): 459-478
Maman, S. Mbwambo, J.; Campbell, J. C., Hogan, M.; Kilonzo, G.P., Weiss, E., & Sweat, M. (2002). HIV-1 Positive Women Report More Lifetime Experiences with Violence: Findings from a Voluntary HIV-1 Counseling and Testing Clinic in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. American Journal of Public Health, 92 (8), 1331-1337.
Maman, S., Mbwambo, J., Hogan, N. M., Kilonzo, G. P., & Sweat, M. D. (2001). Women's barriers to HIV-1 testing and disclosure: challenges for HIV-1 voluntary counseling and testing. AIDS Care 13, 595-603.
Mirsa, D. (ed.). (2001). The Women’s health data book: A profile of women’s health in the United States. (3rd ed.). Washington, D.C.: Jacobs Institute of Women’s Health and The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation.
Moffitt, T.E., & Caspi, A. (1999). Findings about partner violence from the Dunedin multidisciplinary health and development study. Washington, D.C.: Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics, July, NCJ 170018.
Mwakigile, D.; Mmari, E.; Makwaya, C.; Mbwana, J.; Biberfeld, G.; Mhalu, F.; Sandstrom, E. (2001). Sexual behaviour among youths at high risk for HIV-1 infection in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Sexually Transmitted Infections; 77, 255-259.
Nauman, P., Langford, D., Torres, S., Campbell, J. & Glass, N. (1999). Women battering in primary practice. Family Practice, 16, 343-352.
Outwater A, Abrahams N, Campbell JC. (2005). Women in South Africa: Violence and HIV/AIDS, Intersections and Prevention. Journal of Black Studies, 35, 135-154.
Plichta, S.B. (1996). Violence and abuse: Implications for women’s health. In M.K. Falik & K.S. Collins (Eds). Women’s Health: The Commonwealth Fund Survey. Baltimore, MD., Johns Hopkins University Press, 237-270.
Price, P.J. (1996). The effect of intimate partner abuse, daily stress and social support on infant birth weight in African American mothers. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Wayne State University.
Rennison, C., Welchans, S. (2000). Intimate partner violence. Bureau of Justice Statistics Special Report, Washington, D.C.: Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics, May, NCJ 178247.
Schollenberger, J. Campbell, J., Sharps, P.W., O’Campo, P., Carlson, A., Dienemann, J., & Kub, J. (2003). African American HMO enrollees: Their experience with partner abuse ands its affect on their health and utilization of medical services. Violence Against Women, 9 (5) 599-618.
Sharps. P.W., & Campbell, J.C. (1999). Health consequences for victims of violence in intimate relationships. In X. Arriaga & S. Oskamp (eds.). Violence in Intimate Relationships. Thousand Oaks: Sage, 163-180.
Sharps, P.W., Campbell, J.C., Campbell, D.W., Gary, F. & Webster, D. (2001). The role of alcohol of alcohol use in intimate partner femicide. American Journal of Addictions, 10(2), 1-14.
Sharps, P.W., Koziol-McLain, J., Campbell, J., McFarlane, J. Sachs, C., & Xu, X. (2001). Health care providers missed opportunities for preventing femicide. Preventive Medicine, 33, 373-380.
Walton-Moss, B. J., Manganello, J., Frye, V. & Campbell, J.C. (2005). Risk factors for intimate partner violence and associated injury among urban women. Journal of Community Health, 30, 377-389.
Tjaden, P. & Thoennes, N. (2000). Extent, nature and consequences of intimate partner violence: Findings from the national violence against women survey. Washington, D.C.: US Department of Justice, NCJ 181867.
Torres, S., Campbell, J.C., Campbell, D.W., Ryan. J., King, C., Price, P., Stallings, R., Fuchs, S., & Laude, M. (2000). Abuse during and before pregnancy: Prevalence and cultural correlates. Violence and Victims, 15(3), 3033-322.
Van der Straten, A. King, R.; Grinstead, O.; Serufilira, A.; Allen, S. (1995). Couple communication, sexual coercion and HIV risk reduction in Kigali, Rwanda, AIDS, 9, 935-944.
Van der Straten, A.; King, R. Grinstead, O.; Vitinghoff, E.; Serufilira, A.; Allen, S. (1998). Sexual Coercion, Physical Violence and HIV Infection Among Women in Steady Relationships in Kigali, Rwanda. AIDS and Behavior, 2, 61-73.
Watts, C., Ndlovu, M., Njovana, E., & Keogh, E. (1997). Women, violence and HIV/AIDS in Zimbabwe. SAfAIDS, 5 (2),2-6.
Weiss, E.; Whelan, D. (2000). Gender, sexuality and HIV: making a difference in the lives of young women in developing countries. Sexual and Relationship Therapy, 15(3), 233-245.
Wingood, G. M. (2001). Adverse consequences of intimate partner abuse among women in non-urban domestic violence shelters. American Journal of Preventive Medicine , 19 (4), 270-275.
Wingood, G.M.; DiClemente, R.J. (1997). The Effects of an Abusive Primary Partner on the Condom Use and Sexual Negotiation Practices of African-American Women. American Journal of Public Health, 87, 1016-1018.
Wingood, G.M.; DiClemente, R.J., Harrington, K., Lang, D., Davies, S., Hook, E. W., Oh, M., & Harden, J. W. (2006). Efficacy of an HIV prevention program among female adolescents experiencing gender-based violence. American Journal of Public Health, 96,, 1085-1090.
Wisner, C. L., Gilmer, T. P., Saltzman, L. E., Zink, T. M. (1999). Intimate partner violence against women: Do victims cost health plans more? Journal of Family Practice. 48 (6), 439-443.
Wood, K.; Maforah, F.; Jewkes, R. (1998). ‘He forced me to love him’: Putting violence on adolescent sexual health agendas. Social Science and Medicine, 47(2), 233-242.
Woods, A. B., Page, G., O’Campo, P., Pugh, L., Ford, D., & Campbell, J. C., (In review). The Mediation Effect of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Symptoms on the Relationship of Intimate Partner Violence and IFN-γ Levels.
Worth, D. (1989). Sexual Decision-Making and AIDS: Why Condom Promotion among Vulnerable Women is Likely to Fail. Studies in Family Planning, 20, 297-307.
Wyatt, G. E., Myers, H. F., Williams, J. K., Ramirez-Kitchen, C., Loeb, T., Vargas-Carmona, J., Wyatt, L. E., Chin, D., & Presley, N. (2002). Does a history of trauma contribute to HIV risk for women of color? Implications for prevention and policy. American Journal of Public Health, 92 (4),660-665.
Email to a Friend: